Nineteen eighty-nine was a good year for freedom. Only in China did the Communist Party crush the protestors who slowly took possession of Tiananmen Square from April 14 on. When the tanks and soldiers rolled in on June 3-4, there was hardly any concrete to be seen on the square. Up to 1,500 people were massacred.

Even so, Tiananmen left us an image of hope: the man who repeatedly blocked a tank while the soldier driving it never ran him over. Internet searches for “tank man” in China come up empty. One here will get you nearly nine million results. The man’s defiance and the soldier’s refusal to kill him still threaten the Chinese leadership.

In Eastern Europe, communist regimes fell like dominoes. Mikhail Gorbachev’s “Sinatra Doctrine” — Moscow would no longer intervene to prop them up — left the region’s communist leaders to fend for themselves. When citizens took to the streets, all but Romania’s Nicolae Ceausescu blinked rather than give the order to fire.

Cuba had its own 1989. In June, a group of military and state-security officers were arrested and tried for drug trafficking. Four were brought before firing squads. Perhaps these men were also involved in reform efforts. No matter, it is still crystal clear that the scandal bared a regime predicament.

Fidel Castro’s demand for unconditional elite loyalty required a high degree of tolerance for wide-ranging elite behavior. Whether or not he knew about the officers’ activities, full responsibility fell on his governance style. Havana, however, blamed a few bad apples even if two of the men executed — Gen. Arnaldo Ochoa and Colonel Antonio de la Guardia — had long been close to Castro.

Today we are witnessing young people in the Middle East march for freedom. Unlike Eastern Europe, however, Middle Eastern regimes sprung from within and, in that sense, are more akin to China. Autocracies in Egypt and Tunisia withered away with little bloodshed. Not so in Libya where Moammar Gadhafi has unleashed loyal troops, foreign mercenaries and air strikes against the people. Hundreds have already died and the regime no longer controls eastern Libya.

After 1989, Cuba was thought to be next. Bumper stickers proclaiming En el noventa, Fidel revienta! (In 1990, Fidel will burst!) were widely seen in Miami. George H.W. Bush thought freedom would come to Cuba under his watch. Castro, however, stood fast and survived to transfer power to Raúl in 2006.

Be that as it may, the elder Castro’s leadership style is still the heart of the matter. Fidel always preferred governing on his own than through even undemocratic institutions. It took Raúl Castro a while to put the house in order. Now he and his elderly cohorts are trapped.

On the one hand, the thought that they would be the ones to lose power keeps them awake at night. On the other, they are committed to saving Fidel’s legacy which is also their own. Still, Castro’s unwillingness to put the interests of ordinary Cubans at the center of his rule has made Raúl’s task all the harder. Too much time has been lost and the costs now are even steeper.

Cubans are facing layoffs to the tune of 1.8 million over four years. Though there are conflicting reports on whether the first round of 500,000 has even started in earnest, the mere announcement of layoffs suggests a new social contract. “You’re on your own,” the leadership is, in effect, saying.

What’s happening in Libya might be especially troubling for the Cuban leadership. Fidel Castro and Gadhafi once had close relations. We don’t know how much Cubans know about Libyan developments. Elites in the military, the state and the party, however, are well aware of the defections among their Libyan counterparts.

Would young Cubans be willing to risk the regime’s wrath by taking to the streets? Would the regime give the order to fire on them? Would the officers and soldiers pull the trigger? These aren’t idle questions. Incipient reforms are already shaking up Cuban society, and that’s the place to look for change.



Recent Articles

Date Title
2/28/11 Cuba intensifies campaign against dissidents
Anne-Marie Garcia and Paul Haven, Miami Herald
2/28/11 The New Cuba: Where a Citizen Can Go Bankrupt or Prosper
Yoani Sanchez, The Huffington Post
2/28/11 Cuba frees another prominent political prisoner
Paul Haven, Miami Herald
2/28/11 Lawyer for jailed American in Cuba also advocates case of Cuban spies jailed in the U.S.
Frances Robles, Miami Herald
2/25/11 US says Cuba has set date to try detained American
Paul Haven, Miami Herald
2/24/11 Current Record
2/24/11 Cuban officials detain dozens of protesters honoring Zapata
Juan Tamayo, Miami Herald
2/24/11 US says Cuba has set date to try detained American
AP, Miami Herald
2/24/11 Orlando Zapata Tamayo: On The First Anniversary of His Death for Human Rights in Cuba
Yoani Sanchez, The Huffington Post
2/24/11 US denounces Cuba's treatment of dissidents
Paul Haven, AP
2/23/11 Arrival of Cuba offshore oil rig delayed again
Reuters
2/23/11 Dozens arrested as protest gears up in Cuba
Juan Tamayo, El Nuevo Herald
2/23/11 Dead Cuban political prisoner’s mom becomes brave activist
Frances Robles, Miami Herald
2/23/11 Rappers 'Los Aldeanos' clash with police in Cuba
Juan Tamayo, El Nuevo Herald
2/21/11 Still no layoffs in Cuba 5 months after announced
Paul Haven, AP
2/20/11 Uncomfortable Freedoms
Ernesto Morales Licea, Little Brother
2/18/11 Rubio to press for flight restrictions to Cuba
Miami Herald
2/17/11 Rubio's attempt to block new flights to Cuba is rejected
Steve Huettel, St. Petersburg Times
2/17/11 A true terrorism list
Editorial Opinion, Los Angeles Times
2/16/11 Sen. Marco Rubio amendment would bar all flights to Cuba from U.S. airports
Juan Tamayo, El Nuevo Herald
2/16/11 Aseguran que liberar a Gross es beneficioso
EFE, El Nuevo Herald
2/16/11 Rubio's attempt to restrict Cuba flights angers some
AP, Tampa Bay Online
2/16/11 Report: Obama Has Authority to Ease Cuba Embargo
Latin American Herald Tribune
2/16/11 Rubio's ill-considered action on Cuba travel
Editorial Opinion, St. Petersburg Times
2/14/11 Mubarak and Castro: The Self-Deception of Dictators
Angel Sebastian, The Huffington Post
2/14/11 Cuba is no Egypt
Editorial Opinion, Miami Herald
2/13/11 Cuba frees 2 political prisoners against their wishes
Shasta Darlington, CNN
2/10/11 Cuban military officer testifies against militant Luis Posada Carriles
Alfonso Chardy, El Nuevo Herald
2/10/11 Wikileaks: Cuba expected to survive recession
Juan Tamayo, El Nuevo Herald
2/10/11 Fiber-optic communications cable arrives in Cuba
Andrea Rodriguez, Miami Herald
2/10/11 My Blog Is Once Again Visible In Cuba
Yoani Sanchez, The Huffington Post
2/8/11 Cuba unblocks access to controversial blog
Reuters
2/8/11 Internet critic is identified in Cuba
Juan Tamayo, El Nuevo Herald
2/7/11 Cuban dissident who refused exile released
Juan Carlos Chaves, El Nuevo Herald
2/7/11 Cuba seeks 20 years for U.S. contractor
William Booth, Washington Post
2/7/11 Florida airports preparing for higher demand for flights to Cuba
William Gibson and Doreen Hemlock, Sun Sentinel
2/7/11 Hunger Protest Might End
2/4/11 U.S. Must Share Lessons
Jorge Piñon, Miami Herald
2/4/11 Florida lawmakers look to halt Cuba's offshore oil drilling
Lesley Clark, Miami Herald
2/3/11 In a Shift, Cubans Savor Working for Themselves
Victoria Burnett, The New York Times
2/3/11 U.S. Policy Pushes Cuba into the Arms of our Adversaries
Tomas Bilbao, The Havana Note
2/3/11 Cuba gives OK to unusual lawsuit
Juan Tamayo, El Nuevo Herald
2/3/11 Cuba to free 4 opposition prisoners
Paul Haven, Miami Herald
2/3/11 Egypt-like riots not likely at all in Cuba
Juan Tamayo, Miami Herald
2/2/11 Cuba & Remittances: Can the ‘Money in the Mail’ Drive Reform?
Josh Goldstein, Center for Financial Inclusion Blog
2/1/11 Strait Talk
Arturo Lopez-Levy, Foreign Policy
2/1/11 Cuba isolationists lose their hold
Sarah Stephens, Politico
2/1/11 Ted Piccone: To effect change in Havana, support the Cuban people
Ted Piccone, Sun Sentinel
2/1/11 Cuba hands out sentences in mental hospital deaths
Andrea Rodrigues, Miami Herald