Troubled waters

October 12, 2011

EVERY SO often, it can be comforting to revisit the US relationship with Cuba. The world seems so chaotic and unsettling — terrorism, two wars, the Arab Spring — it’s enough to create nostalgia for the moral certainties of the Cold War. Through it all, our relations with Cuba have remained the same; simply, we don’t like the government there.

The premise of our policy through all those decades has been to ostracize and alienate the Cuban government, and give safe haven to the lucky Cubans who risk death to make it to US shores; then, seeing the virtues of freedom, Cubans would feel greater pressure to overthrow their Communist leaders. But the policy has failed. The Castro regime has ruled through 11 US presidents.

President Obama has loosened travel restrictions to Cuba somewhat, allowing for greater exchange of researchers and students. But the core policy has remained, mostly because of the political influence of a vocal Cuban exile population.

Until recently, the cost of the failed policy hasn’t been visible. Now it is. Since our policy has been stuck in the 1960s, it has made us more vulnerable to current safety threats. We are simply too outraged at the never-dying Castros to see it.

In a few months, a Spanish oil company will begin exploratory deepwater drilling off the shores of Cuba, a mere 60 miles from the Florida Keys. The company, Repsol, is the first to search for billions of barrels of oil there using a Chinese-made drilling rig. Cuba is expected to lease various ocean blocks to international companies, but none will be US-owned due to continuing economic prohibitions on dealing with the Cuban government.

For those in the 21st century, the story is disturbing. At a time when the search for oil and jobs is a very high priority, US companies will not compete for a potential windfall so close to our coast.

More threatening, however, is the risk to our shores. Because we have no relationship with Cuba, we have no emergency response agreement with Cuba for oil spills. There are no international accords, as we have with Mexico, for notification, information sharing, or providing resources to respond to an environmental catastrophe.

What we do share is the loop current - an area of warm water that travels up from the Caribbean, often through the Florida straits, and heads up the eastern coast to New England. It would make the United States the prime victim of a spill in Cuban waters. If a large accident should occur, the United States would be responsible for managing oil along hundreds of miles of US waters.

Cuba itself is ill-equipped to deal with an oil spill. The State Department, thankfully, will allow oil spill cleanup companies to be temporarily licensed to Cuba should an accident occur. The Coast Guard in Florida is reviewing potential scenarios, knowing that an oiled loop current is far more dangerous to US citizens than the Castro regime. But they are struggling mightily to work within an overall policy that prohibits most forms of engagement.

Hopefully, the 2010 BP oil spill has terrified the industry enough that sheer self-preservation will make oil drillers ultra-cautious. Repsol, for its part, is a publicly traded powerhouse, with operations in 29 countries. But so, of course, was BP.

The real story here is how little these developments seem to matter to our lawmakers. The usual anti-Cuba congressional contingent, many from Florida, wrote a letter to the president of Repsol, expressing their serious concern with Repsol’s plans to “partner’’ with the “Castro regime.’’ The operations will provide “direct financial benefit to the Castro dictatorship.’’

That’s the only concern? Their condemnation of Fidel and President Raul Castro leaves no room to address, with either Repsol or Cuba, the preventative and response efforts that ought to occur should something terrible happen a short boat ride away from their constituents.

The letter was sent Sept. 27, 2011. It could have been drafted in 1961. There may be something soothing in holding onto Cold War principles when the world seems so mixed up. Or maybe its just blinding.



Recent Articles

Date Title
10/31/11 In Cuba, A Used Car Is No Bargain
Nick Miroff, NPR
10/30/11 Cuba Government Opens 3.2 Million Acres of Idle Land for Individual Use
Latin American Herald Tribune
10/25/11 UN Condemns US Embargo of Cuba _ Again
International Herald Tribune - The New York Times (Global Edition)
10/25/11 End the Embargo, End Castro Regime's Excuse for All Its Failures
The Huffington Post
10/25/11 End the Embargo, End Castro Regime's Excuse for All Its Failures
Yoani Sanchez, Generación Y
10/24/11 U.S. airlines eye more flights to Cuba
USA TODAY Travel
10/24/11 Put U.S. interests above political fray in dealing with Cuban oil drilling
Editorial Opinion, Sun Sentinel
10/22/11 The U.N., the U.S. Embargo, and the 20-Year Rout
The Huffington Post - Blog
10/21/11 Growing Cuban Private Sector Spurs Change: U.S. Group
International Herald Tribune - The New York Times (Global Edition)
10/21/11 Green groups’ double standard on Cuba’s oil drilling plans
Thomas Pyle, The Miami Herald
10/21/11 Survey Finds that Cubans Welcome Reforms
Freedom House Press Release
10/21/11 Cuba suspicious of a Radio/TV Marti baseball contract
Juan Tamayo, The Miami Herald
10/20/11 Cuba policy missteps could delay State nominee
Jose R. Cardenas, Foreign Policy
10/20/11 Majority of Cuban-Americans for warmer US-Cuba ties, poll says, but...
Anya Landau French, Christian Science Monitor
10/19/11 Cuba to Grant Much Larger Plots to Farmers
International Herald Tribune - The New York Times (Global Edition)
10/19/11 Embargo will limit US oversight of planned oil drilling off Cuba coast
Andrew Restuccia, The Hill
10/18/11 U.S. Lawmakers Fret as Cuba Oil Drill Plans Advance
The New York Times
10/17/11 Exclusive-Cuba Probes British Fund, Arrests Top Executive
The New York Times
10/17/11 Cuba Ladies in White march for dead leader Laura Pollan
10/17/11 Cuba's love for the Russian Lada
10/17/11 U.S. Will Inspect Cuban Rig
Russell Gold, The Wall Street Journal
10/17/11 Cuban dissidents voice concern about hospitals as Pollán’s daughter praises mother’s treatment
Juan Tamayo, The Miami Herald
10/17/11 The Cuban Diaspora in the 21st Century
Cuban Research Institute, FIU
10/16/11 Cuba's Ladies in White Stage March, Vow to Continue
10/16/11 Cuba: Ladies In White To Continue Protests After Founder Laura Pollan's Death
10/16/11 Leader's Death a New Challenge for Cuba's 'Ladies'
10/15/11 Venezuela's Chavez heads back to Cuba for more medical tests
10/15/11 Laura Pollan Toledo, Who Rallied Wives of Jailed Cuban Dissidents, Dies at 63
10/15/11 Cuba's Ladies in White Mourn Leader, Vow to Go On
10/15/11 Obama honors Cuban dissident
10/15/11 Castro 'laments' death of hunger-striking dissident
10/15/11 Statement on the passing of Laura Pollán
Cuba Study Group
10/14/11 First Cuban agent freed in US to lobby for fellow agents
10/14/11 Laura Pollan, Who Founded Cuban Protest Group, Dies at 63
10/14/11 Laura Pollan, founder of Cuban protest group, dies
10/14/11 Cuba President Raul Castro seeks term limits on leaders
10/14/11 Cuba Communist Party mulls call for term limits
10/14/11 AP sources: US offered Cuba swap for American
10/14/11 Arrival of Cuba offshore oil rig delayed again
Jeff Franks, Reuters
10/13/11 Number of Cuban migrants has surged in the past year
Alfonso Chardy and Juan Tamayo, The Miami Herald
10/12/11 NO Airport Approved for Cuba Air Service
10/12/11 Current Record
10/11/11 Key West Airport Approved To Offer Flights To Cuba
10/11/11 Cuba’s Economic Reforms: A Window of Opportunity
Raices de Esperanza Blog, Tomas Bilbao
10/11/11 Illegal Cuban migration, after years of decline, is up again
Alfonso Chardy and Juan Tamayo, The Miami Herald
10/10/11 Familiares de 'los cinco cubanos' piden su indulto
10/10/11 Hugo Chavez to Return to Cuba for Medical Tests
10/10/11 Cuba: a tragedy of the commons
Jose Azel, The Miami Herald
10/9/11 AP Interview: Cuba won't unilaterally free Gross
10/9/11 Cubans Rally Around Laura Pollan, Founder of the Ladies in White
10/8/11 Cuban Official - Let Spy Ring Member Come Home
10/8/11 Leader of Cuban Dissident Group in Intensive Care
10/8/11 EE.UU. liber' a un cubano esp'a prisionero desde 1998
10/7/11 Alarc'n pide a Obama dejar volver a Cuba a agente liberado
10/7/11 Convicted Cuban Agent Released From Florida Jail
10/7/11 Report: Cuban diaspora can boost island’s economy
Juan Tamayo, The Miami Herald
10/5/11 Terms of Cuban Spy Release Irritate U.S.-Cuba Ties
10/5/11 New media bring the world closer to Cuba
Mimi Whitefield, The Miami Herald
10/4/11 Cuba: Radio/TV Martí texting is ‘cyberwar’
Juan Tamayo, Miami Herald
10/3/11 Cuba opens doors to MBA studies
Marc Frank, Reuters
10/3/11 The Catholic Church and the destiny of the Cuban nation
Roberto Veiga Gonzalez, From the Island
10/1/11 God and Profits: How the Catholic Church Is Making A Comeback in Cuba
Tim Padgett, Time
10/1/11 First of the 'Cuban Five' spies set to be released from prison Friday
Jay Weaver, Miami Herald